PRIMER VERNIG: MALNAR IZGUBIL TOŽBO PROTI DNEVNIKU. NAPOVEDAL PRITOŽBO

| 13/06/2012

Okrajno sodišče v Ljubljani je danes po poročanju časnikov Delo in Dnevnik zavrnilo odškodninsko tožbo novomeškega atletskega trenerja Slavka Malnarja proti časopisni hiši Dnevnik. Malnar je zahteval 19.900 evrov odškodnine zaradi člankov, ki jih je Dnevnik leta 2007 objavil v zvezi z izpovedjo odbojkarice Jane Vernig, v kateri je svojega nekdanjega trenerja obtožila spolne zlorabe, ki naj bi se zgodila pred dvema desetletjema. Slavko Malnar je že napovedal pritožbo.

Sodišče ni pritrdilo trenerjevi tožbi, v kateri je trdil, da je časnik Dnevnik s sedmimi objavljenimi članki blatil njegovo dobro ime, zatrjeval neresnice, ga žalil in sprožil javni pogrom proti njemu. Sodnica Alenka Kočevar Nosan v sodbi meni, da so novinarji Dnevnika spoštovali novinarski kodeks, namen člankov pa naj ne bi bil zaničevanje tožnika, ampak opozoriti na problem spolnih zlorab.

Slavko Malnar je za Novomeški Čuvar povedal, da meni, da sodba ni pravilna. „Navkljub materialnim dokazom o neupravičenosti obtožb je sodišče (kot lahko razumem razlago) odločilo, da so mnenja strokovnjakov (ki so jim bila predstavljena le stališča in razlaga z njihove strani) dovolj, da je bil Dnevnik upravičen do objave inkriminiranih člankov. Menim, da so bila nekatera dejstva (tako tudi kar nekaj pravnikov, oziroma vseh, ki sem jim gradivo dal na vpogled ) prezrta in napačno kvalificirana. Žal se zdi, da je za Dnevnik postalo pomembno dokazati le pravno upravičenost, ne pa dejanska dejstva, ki tistim, ki jih poznajo, prikažejo drugačno sliko.

Malnar napoveduje pritožbo. „V pripravi je pritožba na odločitev in bo v zakonito predpisanem času vložena. Glede na tematiko in interese, pa se zdi, da bo do konca zgodbe preteklo še kar nekaj časa.“

Malnar je sicer tožil tudi nekatere druge medijske hiše. Kot je povedal tožba proti Dolenjskemu listu že ni zaključena, proti drugim medijem pa so se tožbe končale s poravnavo, in sicer z nakazilom določenega zneska za varno hišo v Novem mestu in javnim opravičilom.

Po drugi strani so pri Dnevniku seveda zadovoljni z izrečeno sodbo. Kot je povedal Sven Berdon, eden izmed avtorjev člankov in tudi urednik črne kronike pri Dnevniku, so tako sodbo pričakovali. „Novinarji Dnevika smo spoštovali novinarske standarde.“ Morebitne pritožbe ni želel komentirati.

Jana Vernig je v svoji izjavi za Dnevnik opisala domnevno zlorabo, ki naj bi jo zagrešil atletski trener. Ko je bila stara 12 let, naj bi jo trener v svoji pisarni poljubljal in jo posedal na kolena. To naj bi se dogajalo leto in pol, potem pa je atletiko nehala trenirati. Jana Vernig je trenerja kazensko ovadila, vendar je zadeva zastarala.

Malnar je v tožbi zapisal, da ga je Dnevnik neupravičeno prikazal kot storilca kaznivih dejanj. Iz člankov ga je bilo mogoče prepoznati, pred objavo pa naj novinarji z njim ne bi govorili, tako da ni mogel povedati svoje plati zgodbe.

Sodišče je v svoji sodbi zapisalo, da trditev tožnika, da ga novinarji niso poklicali, ni resnična. Z njim so govorili vsi trije novinarji (Ranka Ivelja, Sven Berdon, Dragana Stankovič). Sodnica jre tudi ocenila, da je bila izpoved Jane Vernig prepričljiva in da so imeli avtorji člankov utemeljen razlog, da ji verjamejo. Po mnenju sodnice naj bi bila pravica do svobode izražanja v tem primeru prednost pred pravico do zasebnosti in osebnostnih pravic. Namen člankov naj ne bi bil osebna diskreditacija, v člankih pa se prepoznavnosti tožnika v njegovem domačem okolju ni dalo izogniti. Sodišče je Malnarju naložilo tudi plačilo pravdnih stroškov Dnevnika, poročata Delo in Dnevnik.

Oznake: , ,

Rubrika: Polis

Komentarji (344)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

Sites That Link to this Post

  1. sam waltonman | 11/06/2014
  2. cheap viagra radio ad | 18/06/2014
  3. background screening | 19/06/2014
  4. pharmacie andorre cialis | 20/06/2014
  5. iherb coupon | 20/06/2014
  6. iherb coupon | 20/06/2014
  7. somanabolic muscle maximizer reviews | 20/06/2014
  8. iherb coupons | 20/06/2014
  9. click here | 21/06/2014
  10. best plastic surgeons in nyc | 21/06/2014
  11. highline residences tiong bahru | 22/06/2014
  12. iherb discount code | 22/06/2014
  13. pharmacie andorre cialis | 22/06/2014
  14. tanning salon super dark tanning | 23/06/2014
  15. vladislav davidzon | 23/06/2014
  16. best dentist in kenosha | 23/06/2014
  17. cheap seo services | 23/06/2014
  18. buy cialis | 26/06/2014
  19. cialis le vrai | 27/06/2014
  20. cialis mode d'emploi | 29/06/2014
  21. Van hall tapes the original phone humor | 29/06/2014
  22. Effective Marketing Tools | 29/06/2014
  23. where to buy camera accessories in delhi | 30/06/2014
  24. directory | 01/07/2014
  25. hoeren in | 01/07/2014
  26. List of top girls Schools in delhi | 01/07/2014
  27. Dr Johan Venter Urologist Pretoria urospes | 03/07/2014
  28. Best SEO Programs | 04/07/2014
  29. Health | 04/07/2014
  30. water ionizer | 05/07/2014
  31. corvette wiring harness | 05/07/2014
  32. clean | 05/07/2014
  33. Finance | 05/07/2014
  34. somanabolic muscle maximizer | 06/07/2014
  35. Liberty | 07/07/2014
  36. prix cialis 5 | 08/07/2014
  37. kolikkopelit.widezone.net | 08/07/2014
  38. iherb coupon code | 08/07/2014
  39. best priced gold in africa | 08/07/2014
  40. iherb coupon | 09/07/2014
  41. go pro camera | 09/07/2014
  42. workout obsession | 09/07/2014
  43. weight loss pills that work | 09/07/2014
  44. soundcloud downloader | 09/07/2014
  45. iherb coupon codes | 09/07/2014
  46. iherb coupons | 10/07/2014
  47. iherb coupons | 10/07/2014
  48. prix cialis viagra | 10/07/2014
  49. new books on lung cancer | 10/07/2014
  50. mark cobb | 10/07/2014
  51. pizamy dzieciece | 10/07/2014
  52. Opzioni Binarie | 11/07/2014
  53. license key | 11/07/2014
  54. how to detox your body naturally | 11/07/2014
  55. clash of clans cheats | 11/07/2014
  56. Tech | 11/07/2014
  57. bankruptcy attorney Miami | 11/07/2014
  58. Process Servers in Chicago, Illinois | 12/07/2014
  59. clash of clans cheats | 12/07/2014
  60. School | 12/07/2014
  61. Diindolylmethane | 12/07/2014
  62. clash of clans cheats | 12/07/2014
  63. We Buy Houses in Litchfield, CT | 12/07/2014
  64. app developers | 13/07/2014
  65. tipps reisen | 13/07/2014
  66. water ionizer comparisons | 13/07/2014
  67. adelgaza 20 | 13/07/2014
  68. alkaline water machine | 14/07/2014
  69. cialis pas cher en pharmacie | 15/07/2014
  70. macanudo cigars | 15/07/2014
  71. Austin Luxury Bathroom Remodeling | 15/07/2014
  72. direct payday loans | 15/07/2014
  73. Tanie noclegi | 15/07/2014
  74. LACAN | 16/07/2014
  75. Free YouTube Views | 16/07/2014
  76. air traffic services | 16/07/2014
  77. cameras | 16/07/2014
  78. baby gifts | 16/07/2014
  79. UK free bets and signup bonuses | 17/07/2014
  80. Movemynt Products | 17/07/2014
  81. LINK M88 | 17/07/2014
  82. at home | 18/07/2014
  83. Homes For Sale in Plainfield IL | 18/07/2014
  84. Downers Grove IL Real Estate | 18/07/2014
  85. geo news live urdu video | 18/07/2014
  86. his comment is here | 18/07/2014
  87. hoteles en cancun | 18/07/2014
  88. backpacking tips | 19/07/2014
  89. best price services | 19/07/2014
  90. https://twitter.com/secretmoneysysx | 19/07/2014
  91. metodo del ritmo para mujeres irregulares | 19/07/2014
  92. forum | 19/07/2014
  93. cialis commercial | 19/07/2014
  94. the terrible twos | 19/07/2014
  95. liposuction prices | 20/07/2014
  96. dallas | 20/07/2014
  97. las vegas seo company | 21/07/2014
  98. Horses for sale | 21/07/2014
  99. Number Plates | 21/07/2014
  100. How to make money fast | 21/07/2014
  101. seo in pueblo Colorado | 21/07/2014
  102. bad credit payday loans guaranteed approval direct lenders | 21/07/2014
  103. Charles | 21/07/2014
  104. how to get on vevo | 21/07/2014
  105. clash of clans hack | 22/07/2014
  106. costa rica stadt | 22/07/2014
  107. how to practice to last longer in bed | 22/07/2014
  108. Attorney 816-524-0404 | 22/07/2014
  109. Best dentist in Cambridge | 23/07/2014
  110. ??????????? ?Θ??? ????Σ | 23/07/2014
  111. ebay japan | 23/07/2014
  112. berita hari ini | 23/07/2014
  113. most fat burning exercise | 23/07/2014
  114. umowa zlecenie | 23/07/2014
  115. naprawa tabletów | 24/07/2014
  116. mercato | 24/07/2014
  117. autogaz poznan | 24/07/2014
  118. kaffeevollautomat test gastronomie | 24/07/2014
  119. savannah immigration lawyer | 24/07/2014
  120. napedy bram przemyslowych | 25/07/2014
  121. Bail from County Jail | 25/07/2014
  122. Section 125 Plan | 26/07/2014
  123. Read Full Report | 27/07/2014
  124. spelautomater | 27/07/2014
  125. Taxi | 27/07/2014
  126. cialis on line | 27/07/2014
  127. Manifestation Miracle Review | 27/07/2014
  128. Dvla number plates | 27/07/2014
  129. rate of uk payday loans | 28/07/2014
  130. Get payday loan today | 28/07/2014
  131. fajsdgjfashdjfaksjdhkfa | 28/07/2014
  132. seo company in india | 28/07/2014
  133. how do i make my boyfriend last longer in bed | 29/07/2014
  134. austin tx dentist | 29/07/2014
  135. Altieri Gilmore LLP Attorneys | 29/07/2014
  136. mining bitcoin | 29/07/2014
  137. cialis generic | 29/07/2014
  138. Job news | 29/07/2014
  139. sacrifice of the king | 29/07/2014
  140. salon kosmetyczny Kraków | 29/07/2014
  141. meble do szkoly | 30/07/2014
  142. opakowania jubilerskie | 30/07/2014
  143. internetowa hurtownia fryzjerska | 30/07/2014
  144. train horn kit for car | 30/07/2014
  145. win prizes like Wii and ipod, it's fast, easy and fun. join us | 30/07/2014
  146. Business | 30/07/2014
  147. cialis jean coutu | 31/07/2014
  148. PLR money Business In a Box Monster PLR | 31/07/2014
  149. credit score gov | 31/07/2014
  150. seo derby | 31/07/2014
  151. SizeGenetics Medical Type1 Device | 31/07/2014
  152. home & garden | 01/08/2014
  153. watch dogs trainer pc | 01/08/2014
  154. Bariatric Surgery | 01/08/2014
  155. Love story in Hindi | 02/08/2014
  156. Affordable Shopping Online | 02/08/2014
  157. Read More Here | 02/08/2014
  158. This Site | 02/08/2014
  159. DUI Lawyer Denver | 02/08/2014
  160. expendables 3 movie download | 03/08/2014
  161. jobs at my mcdonalds | 03/08/2014
  162. site | 03/08/2014
  163. gogol spain | 03/08/2014
  164. click at this website | 04/08/2014
  165. remxgxncbxvemdfchnf | 04/08/2014
  166. breaking news | 04/08/2014
  167. home | 04/08/2014
  168. myfreecam token generator 2014 | 05/08/2014
  169. Movies Reviews | 05/08/2014
  170. granier | 05/08/2014
  171. download expendables 3 free | 05/08/2014
  172. expendables 3 trailer song download | 05/08/2014
  173. visit here | 05/08/2014
  174. Productivity tips | 06/08/2014
  175. download free The Expendables 3 no registration | 06/08/2014
  176. Miles fit | 06/08/2014
  177. utorrent free The Expendables 3 download | 07/08/2014
  178. where to download The Expendables 3 | 07/08/2014
  179. napoleon hill nook | 07/08/2014
  180. tynki|posadzki | 08/08/2014
  181. szkolenie bhp | 08/08/2014
  182. you can find out more | 08/08/2014
  183. download The Expendables 3 free online | 08/08/2014
  184. fotografia slubna Rzeszów | 08/08/2014
  185. Stena | 08/08/2014
  186. nieznany numer | 08/08/2014
  187. Frontline Commando 2 hack ifunbox | 08/08/2014
  188. revistas de decoracion de interiores | 08/08/2014
  189. Rec Tec Grills | 08/08/2014
  190. gmc | 08/08/2014
  191. download free The Expendables 3 online | 09/08/2014
  192. nails | 09/08/2014
  193. women s clothing online shopping | 09/08/2014
  194. havearkitekt | 09/08/2014
  195. indretningsarkitekt | 09/08/2014
  196. cialis canada online pharmacy | 10/08/2014
  197. health | 10/08/2014
  198. seo marketing | 10/08/2014
  199. ancient agate | 10/08/2014
  200. plumbers oklahoma city ok | 11/08/2014
  201. sexleksak | 11/08/2014
  202. Where to buy vibration machine | 11/08/2014
  203. free search engine submission | 11/08/2014
  204. FREE LIFETIME SUPPORT | 12/08/2014
  205. water ionizer | 12/08/2014
  206. cialis professional | 12/08/2014
  207. wet pussy | 13/08/2014
  208. jumbo loans Kennesaw | 13/08/2014
  209. alkaline water | 13/08/2014
  210. epic fails 2014 | 13/08/2014
  211. dmm | 13/08/2014
  212. Press Release Distribution | 13/08/2014
  213. advice | 14/08/2014
  214. Technician | 14/08/2014
  215. urban | 14/08/2014
  216. vanquis | 14/08/2014
  217. commercial real estate brokers | 15/08/2014
  218. parkingi w pyrzowicach | 15/08/2014
  219. fda | 15/08/2014
  220. paleo recipe book | 15/08/2014
  221. download | 15/08/2014
  222. the lovelady center | 16/08/2014
  223. seborrheic dermatitis remedies | 16/08/2014
  224. lovelady center book | 16/08/2014
  225. modern pet furniture | 16/08/2014
  226. cialis 5 mg vendita | 16/08/2014
  227. free streaming music | 16/08/2014
  228. automobile news | 16/08/2014
  229. tubeviperx software | 17/08/2014
  230. the best online super store | 17/08/2014
  231. immediate annuity rates | 17/08/2014
  232. Ice maker repair | 17/08/2014
  233. Graduates | 17/08/2014
  234. how to delay your period with pills | 17/08/2014
  235. скачать хинди Неудержимые 3 2013 | 18/08/2014
  236. chinese lanterns | 18/08/2014
  237. shot | 18/08/2014
  238. ??µ???ατ??? | 18/08/2014
  239. Mira Vanlaere | 18/08/2014
  240. love art | 19/08/2014
  241. Ollie Bottin | 19/08/2014
  242. Ogloszenia Rzeszów | 19/08/2014
  243. CLICK HERE | 20/08/2014
  244. pediatric dentist in the woodlands | 20/08/2014
  245. black mini dress | 20/08/2014
  246. Binary Options Education course | 20/08/2014
  247. caffeine withdrawal headache | 21/08/2014
  248. cuban cigars switzerland | 22/08/2014
  249. yaki onigiri | 22/08/2014
  250. cigars switzerland | 22/08/2014
  251. massage continuing education | 22/08/2014
  252. Find Continuing Education | 22/08/2014
  253. ?ετα??αφ?? στ? ???µÎ±??α | 23/08/2014
  254. erotik cam | 23/08/2014
  255. habanos cuban cigars | 23/08/2014
  256. Lookup by Phone | 23/08/2014
  257. cuban cigar | 23/08/2014
  258. cohiba cigars | 23/08/2014
  259. DIESEL | 23/08/2014
  260. Lose weight fast | 23/08/2014
  261. good | 24/08/2014
  262. prezzo cialis farmacia | 24/08/2014
  263. Single Parties | 24/08/2014
  264. kargo | 25/08/2014
  265. Chicago Wedding Videographer | 25/08/2014
  266. cccam server | 25/08/2014
  267. M88 | 25/08/2014
  268. Popcorn Removal | 25/08/2014
  269. opportunities to work from home | 26/08/2014
  270. Fence Repair | 26/08/2014
  271. YEPI 2 | 26/08/2014
  272. CLASH OF CLANS CHEAT | 26/08/2014
  273. Toilet Repair | 26/08/2014
  274. Countertop Installation | 26/08/2014
  275. shakeology samples | 27/08/2014
  276. Flat Fee MLS Realtor IL | 27/08/2014
  277. www | 27/08/2014
  278. wholesale makeup | 28/08/2014
  279. cozy cove | 28/08/2014
  280. Skip Tracing | 28/08/2014
  281. Halifax Real Estate Agents | 29/08/2014
  282. FSBO Dallas TX | 30/08/2014
  283. cialis 5 mg effetti collaterali | 30/08/2014
  284. yoga honk kong soho | 30/08/2014
  285. MovieStarPlanet Cheats | 31/08/2014
  286. Earn Money | 31/08/2014
  287. Konstantinos | 01/09/2014
  288. pest control houston review | 01/09/2014
  289. ice bucket challenge | 01/09/2014
  290. przebijanie uszu koszalin | 01/09/2014
  291. Cialis | 02/09/2014
  292. tramadol online | 02/09/2014
  293. buy xenical online | 02/09/2014
  294. college help | 03/09/2014
  295. basketball | 03/09/2014
  296. passionate relationship | 03/09/2014
  297. get facebook likes | 04/09/2014
  298. cash for gold | 04/09/2014
  299. send food stuff to abroad | 04/09/2014
  300. plum lipstick | 05/09/2014
  301. acheter cialis sur internet forum | 06/09/2014
  302. Wedding Photos | 06/09/2014
  303. dubai escorts | 06/09/2014
  304. esporradela facial | 07/09/2014
  305. giochi di cucina | 07/09/2014
  306. Womens Lingerie | 07/09/2014
  307. incesto real | 07/09/2014
  308. working ios cheat | 07/09/2014
  309. slot machines games online | 07/09/2014
  310. How to hack android games | 08/09/2014
  311. testosterone and premature ejaculation | 08/09/2014
  312. cialis | 08/09/2014
  313. christmas gift ideas | 08/09/2014
  314. Mobile Window Tinting | 08/09/2014
  315. xlovecam telecharger generateur de code | 08/09/2014
  316. banana blue | 08/09/2014
  317. psycholog plock | 08/09/2014
  318. hearthstone arena guide | 09/09/2014
  319. Computer Service | 09/09/2014
  320. marketing companies perth | 09/09/2014
  321. Cialis | 09/09/2014
  322. epic fails 2014 | 09/09/2014
  323. grounding kundalini | 09/09/2014
  324. See It Here | 10/09/2014
  325. How to Make Money from Home | 10/09/2014
  326. factoring service | 10/09/2014
  327. affordable seo services packages | 11/09/2014
  328. loyal 9 reviews | 11/09/2014
  329. hecigarette review | 11/09/2014
  330. arkitekter kobenhavn | 12/09/2014
  331. poop bags | 12/09/2014
  332. se hack | 12/09/2014
  333. se hack | 12/09/2014
  334. konverteringsoptimering | 14/09/2014
  335. Gulf Shores condo Rentals | 14/09/2014
  336. samaa news news urdu | 14/09/2014
  337. stopthestresstoday.com/contact | 14/09/2014
  338. metal roofing dallas fort worth | 15/09/2014
  339. Benefits of a membership to Car-Haul Jobs | 15/09/2014
  340. Eugenia Kager | 16/09/2014
  341. Cleaning Sydney | 16/09/2014
  342. internet | 16/09/2014
  343. Pegawai Tadbir Diplomatik M41 | 17/09/2014
  344. event atms | 17/09/2014